Track saws are portable saws that are specifically designed to make long, straight cuts. The are valuable in ripping down large sheet goods so that they are more manageable to use on table saws and band saws. Track saws very quickly break down large sheet goods with minimal setup time. Most systems don’t require extra clamping to make accurate and straight cuts.
They are very similar in function, but they do have a few differences.
Track saws are designed to be used with track systems. These tracks are long rails that keep the saw on a straight path. Many track saws also incorporate plunging functionality. This allows the saw to start cutting at the end of a large workpiece rather than having to hang off the end of the workpiece.
Circular saws don’t have included tracks by default. There are some systems available that can convert a circular saw to a track saw, like the Accu-Cut system from Kreg.
Track saws are definitely a specialty tool. They may have limited uses but they perform very well for a specific set of jobs. If you regularly purchase 4×8 sheets of plywood or MDF and need them broken down quickly and accurately, a track saw has a place in your shop.
You might be able to get away with a simple straight-edge, though.
The Quick Answer
The DEWALT DCS520 is our favorite track saw between the two saws reviewed here. Its extra safety features as well as cordless mobility make this saw a win in our book.
If you’d prefer corded power, the MAKITA would also be a great addition to your shop if the extra features aren’t as compelling to you.
MAKITA SP6000
The SP6000 track saw kit includes a plunging saw along with 55″ of track. At nearly 5′ long, this track can handle some pretty long cuts. A 4×8 sheet of plywood can be cut in one motion without having to reposition the track.
With 12 amps under the hood, the MAKITA isn’t the most powerful saw on the market but it’ll power through just about anything you throw at it. The saw tilts to 45 degrees, which is helpful for making long mitered corners. This can be used when building caseworks with mitered edges.
A soft-start trigger is a welcome addition. This track saw doesn’t require holddown clamps to cut so preventing excessive start up vibrations keeps the saw on its intended cut line.
A handful of features keep the saw in ideal operating conditions to extend the life of the tool. First, a variable speed allows the user to adjust blade speed for different materials and blades. Second, electronic speed controllers help maintain optimum power when cutting through tough spots. Third, a torque limiter keeps the motor from overheating and burning out prematurely.
Overall, we really like the MAKITA SP6000. It’s a standard and well-built saw that will earn its keep in any garage.
DEWALT DCS520
DEWALT’s cordless 60V MAX DCS520 track saw kit expands upon the proven 60V line. At 59″, the track is just barely under 5′ long, so all standard sheet goods can be ripped in half in one shot. The 60V MAX batteries delivered plenty of juice for heavy duty 3/4″ plywood and MDF.
The blade tilts to a hair past 45-degrees so mitered rip cuts are easily accomplished on this saw. We’d usually use a table saw for this kind of cut but the DEWALT gives another option.
We really liked the safety features on this track saw. An integrated riving knife keeps the kerf from pinching the blade and bogging the system down, or worse, causing a dangerous kickback scenario. An anti-kickback system also adds an extra measure of safety that we appreciate.
While track saws don’t often need to cut absolutely clean lines, the DCS520’s zero-clearance footplate cuts very clean lines and prevents chipout seen on most other competing models.
Also notable for the DEWALT is its industry-leading warranty. Should you have any issues, the folks at DEWALT stand behind their products and will ensure that any defects or faults are promptly remedied.
So Which Track Saw Is Best?
We’ve summarized the strengths and weaknesses of each saw above. We’ll continue to pit them against each other below to determine which is the best track saw for your workshop. Beyond these summaries, full reviews for each tool can be found here:
Scoring will be based on each saw’s performance in four categories. Also, units can score equally if deserved in a particular category (e.g. a first, second, third, etc isn’t forced). For this comparison, the max score possible is set at 100 and the minimum score is 20.
Which Track Saw is the Most Powerful?
Exemplary = 25 points
Satisfactory = 15 points
Below Average = 5 points
This is a tough comparison since the MAKITA relies on a corded AC power source while the DEWALT uses a cordless DC battery. The two really can’t be compared as better or worse but there are some benefits to having always-on power from a corded saw. Conversely, there are benefits to having power ‘anywhere’ with the cordless system.
For these reasons, both saws earn satisfactory marks.
MAKITA and DEWALT earn 15 points.
Which Track is the Longest?
Exemplary = 25 points
Satisfactory = 15 points
Below Average = 5 points
The track included in the MAKITA kit is 55 inches while the DEWALT is a touch longer at 59 inches. Both track lengths will cut a 4×8 sheet in half with ease so there aren’t any limitations out-of-the-box.
Both track systems can be expanded with additional tracks to any length desired, so longer lengths are equally attainable.
MAKITA and DEWALT earn 15 points.
Which Saw has the Best Price?
Exemplary = 25 points
Satisfactory = 15 points
Below Average = 5 points
At the time of writing, both saws are between $400-$500. Prices fluctuate with sales so keep an eye on the prices.
The DEWALT tends to run a smidge higher than the MAKITA but both saws are priced comparably.
MAKITA and DEWALT earn 15 points.
Which Track Saw has the Most Features?
Exemplary = 25 points
Satisfactory = 15 points
Below Average = 5 points
The DEWALT really shines when considering extra features. We’re glad to see extra safety measures included in the DCS520.
A riving knife and anti-kickback mechanism helps keep accidents at bay when making long cuts through tough materials.
The MAKITA is a standard affair and doens’t include anything extra or exclude anything crucial.
DEWALT earns 25 points, MAKITA earns 15 points.
Final Results
Both saws are impressive additions to the workshop but the DDEWALT takes our top spot with its extra safety features. Its cordless construction is also a plus for unencumbered operations; this is largely a function of preference.
If you’re looking for a no-frills track saw with always-on corded power, check out the MAKITA.
If you’re looking for our highest recommendation, the DEWALT is the ticket for a solid and high-performing track saw.